The Japan Times - Fact Check: Pediatricians say homemade baby formula unsafe

EUR -
AED 3.804709
AFN 77.173939
ALL 98.583483
AMD 410.170979
ANG 1.869121
AOA 946.266488
ARS 1091.696847
AUD 1.652874
AWG 1.867189
AZN 1.75698
BAM 1.947609
BBD 2.093953
BDT 126.010038
BGN 1.95527
BHD 0.390354
BIF 3069.82991
BMD 1.035888
BND 1.398989
BOB 7.166858
BRL 6.022445
BSD 1.037118
BTN 90.680748
BWP 14.394184
BYN 3.393993
BYR 20303.411698
BZD 2.083198
CAD 1.487002
CDF 2957.461198
CHF 0.937629
CLF 0.026208
CLP 1005.650783
CNY 7.551362
CNH 7.555443
COP 4326.470573
CRC 526.276472
CUC 1.035888
CUP 27.451041
CVE 109.802144
CZK 25.116205
DJF 184.679725
DKK 7.459421
DOP 64.109138
DZD 140.378603
EGP 52.090059
ERN 15.538325
ETB 130.831589
FJD 2.396323
FKP 0.853144
GBP 0.83723
GEL 2.894167
GGP 0.853144
GHS 15.971827
GIP 0.853144
GMD 74.583747
GNF 8966.117981
GTQ 8.0182
GYD 216.977455
HKD 8.065649
HNL 26.570814
HRK 7.644388
HTG 135.656847
HUF 405.712934
IDR 16938.276593
ILS 3.67961
IMP 0.853144
INR 90.726365
IQD 1358.586178
IRR 43610.899592
ISK 146.55742
JEP 0.853144
JMD 163.769651
JOD 0.734858
JPY 157.76164
KES 133.751058
KGS 90.588209
KHR 4161.16358
KMF 489.923611
KPW 932.299632
KRW 1501.748589
KWD 0.319613
KYD 0.864257
KZT 536.1101
LAK 22552.152144
LBP 92872.60801
LKR 309.627795
LRD 206.378049
LSL 19.311296
LTL 3.058709
LVL 0.626598
LYD 5.094476
MAD 10.380642
MDL 19.414162
MGA 4867.639514
MKD 61.484154
MMK 3364.52496
MNT 3519.948731
MOP 8.319311
MRU 41.348303
MUR 48.345228
MVR 15.963466
MWK 1798.319426
MXN 21.359003
MYR 4.594183
MZN 66.203332
NAD 19.311296
NGN 1556.409493
NIO 38.079586
NOK 11.649528
NPR 145.088
NZD 1.829674
OMR 0.398845
PAB 1.037138
PEN 3.849882
PGK 4.148211
PHP 60.192879
PKR 288.960873
PLN 4.202068
PYG 8171.475361
QAR 3.781559
RON 4.97465
RSD 117.058453
RUB 100.560324
RWF 1446.100139
SAR 3.885187
SBD 8.742296
SCR 14.903437
SDG 622.558829
SEK 11.30683
SGD 1.401546
SHP 0.853144
SLE 23.716661
SLL 21722.060714
SOS 592.701546
SRD 36.364899
STD 21440.797435
SVC 9.074747
SYP 13468.620337
SZL 19.300455
THB 34.985578
TJS 11.320091
TMT 3.635968
TND 3.292569
TOP 2.426158
TRY 37.181296
TTD 7.02439
TWD 34.016809
TZS 2635.071065
UAH 43.166438
UGX 3816.94702
USD 1.035888
UYU 45.129762
UZS 13466.548468
VES 61.517319
VND 26176.898654
VUV 122.982745
WST 2.901344
XAF 653.203508
XAG 0.032282
XAU 0.000361
XCD 2.79954
XDR 0.795447
XOF 652.095783
XPF 119.331742
YER 257.884301
ZAR 19.252985
ZMK 9324.238051
ZMW 29.064203
ZWL 333.555627
  • RBGPF

    -0.7000

    65.3

    -1.07%

  • CMSC

    0.1600

    23.5

    +0.68%

  • NGG

    -0.3400

    62.33

    -0.55%

  • RIO

    1.4800

    62.85

    +2.35%

  • RYCEF

    0.0200

    7.52

    +0.27%

  • RELX

    -0.5100

    50.26

    -1.01%

  • VOD

    0.1650

    8.435

    +1.96%

  • AZN

    2.7050

    73.64

    +3.67%

  • GSK

    -0.2900

    37.41

    -0.78%

  • CMSD

    0.0000

    23.82

    0%

  • BTI

    0.2150

    41.315

    +0.52%

  • JRI

    0.0100

    12.84

    +0.08%

  • SCS

    0.0250

    11.585

    +0.22%

  • BCE

    -0.3950

    24.505

    -1.61%

  • BP

    0.6250

    32.295

    +1.94%

  • BCC

    1.1000

    125.85

    +0.87%

Fact Check: Pediatricians say homemade baby formula unsafe
Fact Check: Pediatricians say homemade baby formula unsafe / Photo: Fred DUFOUR - AFP/File

Fact Check: Pediatricians say homemade baby formula unsafe

Social media posts are urging parents who face baby formula shortages to make it themselves. But pediatricians told AFP they do not advise patients to use homemade formula, warning it may lack vitamins and nutrients key to helping infants grow and thrive.

Text size:

One formula recipe, said to be from 1960, has been shared on Facebook hundreds of thousands of times, urging parents to mix evaporated milk, water and Karo corn syrup.

Parents in the United States say purchasing restrictions and price gouging have left them increasingly desperate to get their hands on the food required for infants who are not breastfed. But the American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) cautions against formula made at home.

Tanya Altmann, author of several parenting books and founder of Calabasas Pediatrics in California, agreed.

"I advise my patients not to make homemade infant formula," she told AFP. "It won't meet your baby's essential nutritional needs, can be very dangerous to their growth and development and can even make your baby sick."

Looking at the recipe circulating online, Altmann said the added sugar would not be safe or healthy for infants.

"Karo syrup was once used to help ease constipation, but it is not advised as it's not effective and can even contain harmful bacteria," she said.

Azza Ahmed, an associate professor of nursing at Purdue University, said homemade formula can put a baby at risk of "contamination and infection."

And although parents are feeling stressed by shortages, formula should never be watered down, as this can quickly lead to an imbalance of nutrition, she added.

Social media posts prompted by shortages also claim orange juice mixed with water can be introduced at three weeks of age.

But the Academy of Breastfeeding Medicine warned against juice and other formula substitutes.

"Do not give your baby under six months of age any water, tea, or juice," it said.

Other Facebook posts are recommending that parents substitute goat's milk for formula.

But goat milk lacks nutrients necessary for human babies, according to Gabrina Dixon from Children's National Hospital in Washington, DC. She pointed to its lack of folate and vitamin B12 -- which is necessary to stave off anemia, or a low red blood cell count.

Experts told AFP that concerned parents should consult their pediatricians about feeding options, but urged more open attitudes about switching formula brands or using generic products, especially for children who have not shown signs of sensitivity to ingredients.

Y.Watanabe--JT