The Japan Times - At plastic treaty talks, no united front for industry

EUR -
AED 4.063027
AFN 79.146337
ALL 99.307952
AMD 432.234609
ANG 1.980308
AOA 1013.269087
ARS 1188.466719
AUD 1.764979
AWG 1.991139
AZN 1.891747
BAM 1.955957
BBD 2.231879
BDT 134.300753
BGN 1.955636
BHD 0.417015
BIF 3285.263049
BMD 1.106189
BND 1.477018
BOB 7.637612
BRL 6.230721
BSD 1.105389
BTN 94.369556
BWP 15.299225
BYN 3.61739
BYR 21681.296011
BZD 2.220378
CAD 1.558504
CDF 3178.079947
CHF 0.946881
CLF 0.027372
CLP 1050.392795
CNY 8.054768
CNH 8.02495
COP 4594.830781
CRC 556.944594
CUC 1.106189
CUP 29.313997
CVE 110.27383
CZK 25.085028
DJF 196.835761
DKK 7.461463
DOP 69.805589
DZD 146.932815
EGP 55.963515
ERN 16.592829
ETB 145.50325
FJD 2.560716
FKP 0.852559
GBP 0.84551
GEL 3.042176
GGP 0.852559
GHS 17.144706
GIP 0.852559
GMD 79.842591
GNF 9569.394997
GTQ 8.516902
GYD 232.077616
HKD 8.603254
HNL 28.316115
HRK 7.533474
HTG 143.784661
HUF 406.814161
IDR 18491.786157
ILS 4.088423
IMP 0.852559
INR 94.527134
IQD 1446.687703
IRR 46570.73418
ISK 146.46576
JEP 0.852559
JMD 172.354831
JOD 0.78432
JPY 161.601994
KES 142.957221
KGS 95.895107
KHR 4424.503091
KMF 500.718632
KPW 995.629493
KRW 1617.590142
KWD 0.341065
KYD 0.919891
KZT 556.242951
LAK 23969.428271
LBP 99074.543194
LKR 325.787761
LRD 221.229257
LSL 20.755246
LTL 3.266288
LVL 0.669122
LYD 5.343114
MAD 10.607274
MDL 19.769717
MGA 5102.794459
MKD 62.920355
MMK 2322.391974
MNT 3864.423643
MOP 8.867567
MRU 44.032332
MUR 50.622924
MVR 17.081712
MWK 1918.174351
MXN 22.060187
MYR 4.92669
MZN 70.673374
NAD 20.755246
NGN 1698.164848
NIO 40.703896
NOK 11.447033
NPR 151.31431
NZD 1.927779
OMR 0.425854
PAB 1.106189
PEN 4.064329
PGK 4.519852
PHP 63.150309
PKR 309.863706
PLN 4.243512
PYG 8818.254075
QAR 4.026913
RON 5.066584
RSD 119.268016
RUB 93.188112
RWF 1571.371433
SAR 4.148044
SBD 9.402112
SCR 16.000343
SDG 663.678677
SEK 10.824078
SGD 1.484525
SHP 0.869291
SLE 25.165692
SLL 23196.222457
SOS 631.07998
SRD 40.509368
STD 22895.870054
SVC 9.679178
SYP 14383.439802
SZL 20.755246
THB 37.730966
TJS 12.064815
TMT 3.869044
TND 3.422029
TOP 2.664374
TRY 41.985664
TTD 7.480015
TWD 36.640203
TZS 2927.606014
UAH 45.712892
UGX 4033.000896
USD 1.106189
UYU 46.730715
UZS 14315.463754
VES 77.220697
VND 28394.543808
VUV 136.691051
WST 3.133647
XAF 667.624843
XAG 0.03506
XAU 0.000357
XCD 2.994776
XDR 0.832845
XOF 667.624843
XPF 119.331742
YER 272.017955
ZAR 20.758226
ZMK 9957.02173
ZMW 31.010699
ZWL 356.192269
  • RBGPF

    69.0200

    69.02

    +100%

  • BCC

    -7.4400

    94.63

    -7.86%

  • RYCEF

    -0.0200

    9.78

    -0.2%

  • SCS

    -0.7200

    10.74

    -6.7%

  • CMSD

    -0.1600

    22.67

    -0.71%

  • CMSC

    -0.2400

    22.26

    -1.08%

  • RELX

    0.4600

    51.44

    +0.89%

  • VOD

    0.2500

    9.37

    +2.67%

  • NGG

    3.6100

    69.39

    +5.2%

  • BCE

    0.8400

    22.66

    +3.71%

  • RIO

    -1.4700

    58.43

    -2.52%

  • JRI

    -0.2200

    12.82

    -1.72%

  • GSK

    1.3700

    39.01

    +3.51%

  • AZN

    1.7000

    73.92

    +2.3%

  • BTI

    1.6700

    41.92

    +3.98%

  • BP

    -2.4700

    31.34

    -7.88%

At plastic treaty talks, no united front for industry
At plastic treaty talks, no united front for industry / Photo: Thibaud MORITZ - AFP/File

At plastic treaty talks, no united front for industry

Is virgin plastic production vital or completely unsustainable? For the industry lobbyists at UN talks on plastic pollution, the answer is far from unanimous.

Text size:

The corridors of the Busan Exhibition and Convention Centre, where the treaty to curb plastic pollution is being negotiated, teem with corporate representatives.

There are the chemical and petrochemical firms whose products are the precursors for plastic, the food and cosmetic companies whose packaging depends on it, and the automakers whose vehicles are increasingly full of it.

All back a treaty, but what they want to see in it differs significantly, particularly on the issue of production.

"Production caps and reducing the amount of material in the system would impact those least able to afford it the most," warned Stewart Harris, spokesman for the International Council of Chemical Associations (ICCA).

The body groups global industry associations and is pushing for a treaty focused on waste management rather than manufacturing limits.

"We see the need for more material in the system overall," Harris told AFP, urging a focus on "circularity" instead of restrictions on new production.

- 'A big problem' -

It's a position echoed by some in the auto sector, who say recycled plastic cannot yet meet the stringent safety requirements for vehicles.

Mark Bacchus, senior manager at Toyota, also warned that the electrification of cars will require more plastic to balance out their heavier batteries.

"If we have a scenario where plastics are going to be less available, that's going to cause a big problem for us," he told AFP.

That is not the view taken by the Business Coalition for a Global Plastics Treaty, which groups several hundred firms including multinationals like Nestle, Unilever, Ikea and Lego.

They have endorsed a call for a reduction of production and use, including of single-use products, as well as the possible phaseout of chemicals considered harmful to human health.

Jodie Roussell, global public affairs lead for packaging and sustainability at Nestle, said the position was good business.

"Different members of the value chain have different interests based on their core business," she told AFP.

"We're in the food and beverage industry. Our core interest is a stable climate and a clean environment."

For these companies, a global treaty also offers the chance of a level playing field, forcing everyone to invest in things like redesigning items for reusability and incorporating recycled material into products.

"Businesses can't do it alone, and we need multilateral legislation to be put into place," she said.

- 'Champions of Change' -

The group stops short of endorsing any numerical target for reduction of new plastic production, arguing that the position is so far from being adopted widely that doing so would not advance the talks.

Cutting production is among the most divisive issues on the table for the negotiators from nearly 200 countries.

Even the so-called High Ambition Coalition of countries, led by Rwanda and Norway, have no explicit target for cuts.

One group of mostly smaller businesses believes that is insufficient.

The "Champions of Change" coalition, organised by environmental groups including Greenpeace, brings together around 300 companies, restaurants and other small businesses.

It includes a handful of household names like ice cream maker Ben and Jerry's and bath products giant Lush.

They are urging the treaty to cut plastic production by at least 75 percent by 2040, from 2019 levels.

"A truly ambitious treaty is one that addresses the root causes of plastic pollution and spurs a shift away from single-use," the group argues.

Even among businesses committed to shifting plastic use, there have been challenges.

Unilever, a member of the Business Coalition, has been targeted by Greenpeace over its use of sachet packaging in Asia, where the products are a persistent source of pollution.

The company's latest progress report on its plastic use acknowledges it is still working to "overcome challenges in the development of viable and scalable solutions" for the issue.

Y.Kato--JT