The Japan Times - Nursing shortage forces emergency room closures across Canada

EUR -
AED 3.838524
AFN 78.306837
ALL 98.671743
AMD 418.568849
ANG 1.881052
AOA 955.707946
ARS 1094.170111
AUD 1.654384
AWG 1.881104
AZN 1.778389
BAM 1.965803
BBD 2.107372
BDT 127.28321
BGN 1.962311
BHD 0.393835
BIF 3088.500349
BMD 1.045058
BND 1.416131
BOB 7.212553
BRL 6.191342
BSD 1.043703
BTN 90.1749
BWP 14.486653
BYN 3.415738
BYR 20483.130157
BZD 2.096536
CAD 1.49727
CDF 2974.23363
CHF 0.94607
CLF 0.037402
CLP 1032.046371
CNY 7.577811
CNH 7.584046
COP 4416.685391
CRC 526.722545
CUC 1.045058
CUP 27.694028
CVE 110.626784
CZK 25.096744
DJF 185.866061
DKK 7.461148
DOP 64.049462
DZD 140.757627
EGP 52.564419
ERN 15.675865
ETB 133.462062
FJD 2.44183
FKP 0.860696
GBP 0.842975
GEL 2.994081
GGP 0.860696
GHS 15.812637
GIP 0.860696
GMD 75.244222
GNF 9025.516223
GTQ 8.06638
GYD 218.36307
HKD 8.137942
HNL 26.572902
HRK 7.712053
HTG 136.40609
HUF 409.914471
IDR 16910.287025
ILS 3.740159
IMP 0.860696
INR 90.174734
IQD 1367.245148
IRR 43983.864012
ISK 145.891906
JEP 0.860696
JMD 164.086614
JOD 0.741467
JPY 162.928677
KES 135.167517
KGS 91.388512
KHR 4202.744271
KMF 493.686139
KPW 940.552011
KRW 1494.667571
KWD 0.322003
KYD 0.869828
KZT 543.436806
LAK 22756.202053
LBP 93466.971469
LKR 311.65623
LRD 206.665861
LSL 19.373773
LTL 3.085784
LVL 0.632145
LYD 5.13675
MAD 10.43638
MDL 19.465472
MGA 4893.001625
MKD 61.556067
MMK 3394.306518
MNT 3551.106044
MOP 8.374226
MRU 41.573356
MUR 48.553199
MVR 16.091201
MWK 1809.918994
MXN 21.21524
MYR 4.61968
MZN 66.778242
NAD 19.373587
NGN 1626.120421
NIO 38.405598
NOK 11.756162
NPR 144.27984
NZD 1.831714
OMR 0.402268
PAB 1.043708
PEN 3.88162
PGK 4.189742
PHP 61.035021
PKR 290.916704
PLN 4.21425
PYG 8252.910594
QAR 3.804843
RON 4.975417
RSD 117.116434
RUB 104.371678
RWF 1448.838148
SAR 3.919792
SBD 8.82713
SCR 14.910103
SDG 628.080029
SEK 11.45529
SGD 1.410687
SHP 0.860696
SLE 23.736479
SLL 21914.33654
SOS 596.550906
SRD 36.686747
STD 21630.583621
SVC 9.132692
SYP 13587.839694
SZL 19.381383
THB 35.332878
TJS 11.42386
TMT 3.657702
TND 3.332398
TOP 2.447633
TRY 37.303961
TTD 7.095067
TWD 34.08612
TZS 2629.364885
UAH 43.837061
UGX 3846.561038
USD 1.045058
UYU 45.679386
UZS 13547.173808
VES 58.745903
VND 26204.820851
VUV 124.071344
WST 2.927026
XAF 658.10922
XAG 0.033928
XAU 0.000376
XCD 2.824321
XDR 0.80423
XOF 658.102902
XPF 119.331742
YER 260.320564
ZAR 19.249607
ZMK 9406.772035
ZMW 29.041697
ZWL 336.50814
  • SCS

    0.0200

    11.6

    +0.17%

  • NGG

    0.6600

    60.71

    +1.09%

  • CMSC

    -0.0050

    23.485

    -0.02%

  • GSK

    0.6200

    34.05

    +1.82%

  • BCC

    0.5300

    128.45

    +0.41%

  • BP

    0.3600

    31.49

    +1.14%

  • CMSD

    -0.0900

    23.87

    -0.38%

  • BTI

    0.4800

    37.05

    +1.3%

  • RBGPF

    61.2800

    61.28

    +100%

  • RIO

    0.4400

    61.56

    +0.71%

  • JRI

    0.0200

    12.55

    +0.16%

  • AZN

    0.4000

    68.6

    +0.58%

  • BCE

    0.0700

    23.22

    +0.3%

  • RYCEF

    0.2800

    7.55

    +3.71%

  • RELX

    0.1300

    49.39

    +0.26%

  • VOD

    0.0200

    8.4

    +0.24%

Nursing shortage forces emergency room closures across Canada
Nursing shortage forces emergency room closures across Canada / Photo: Cole Burston - AFP/File

Nursing shortage forces emergency room closures across Canada

An acute nursing shortage is clogging or even closing hospital emergency rooms across Canada, pushing an already stressed national health system to the brink with potentially severe consequences for patient care.

Text size:

Burnout from the Covid-19 pandemic, abuse from patients and salary discontent have seen nursing staff quitting their jobs in droves, and experts say the situation is only likely to worsen.

The impact on emergency care is such that Ottawa police recently had to take a shooting victim to hospital in their squad car, rather than wait for an ambulance, and an elderly woman who fell and broke her hip was forced to wait six hours for help from paramedics based 100 kilometers (62 miles) away.

Over the summer and into the fall, staffing shortages meant dozens of emergency rooms were forced to close -- sometimes for a night or a weekend, sometimes longer.

Wait times to see an ER doctor have soared to 12, 16, 20 hours -- or more.

"They're numb, deflated and feeling hopeless," said Cathryn Hoy, president of the Ontario Nurses' Association. Herself a nurse for 20 years, she described the situation as "critical."

Amelie Inard, 32, was taken to an ER in Montreal this week, in extreme pain and peeing blood.

The place was packed, and an overwrought nurse told her to describe her condition "in one sentence, really quickly, because of how busy they were," Inard said.

She eventually left in frustration, without seeing a doctor.

Hospital workloads are rising, Hoy said, along with patients' exasperation over extended wait times, leading to a spiking of violence against nurses.

Several nurses told AFP they had been punched, scratched or spat on, and had trays, dishes and feces thrown at them.

- 'Crazy conditions' -

In the capital Ottawa, ambulances were unavailable on more than 1,000 occasions from January to July, as paramedics were stuck waiting to unload patients at crowded ERs.

A hospital in Peterborough, east of Toronto, in the past week was forced to treat patients on gurneys in the parking lot because its ER was full, said Hoy.

In Manitoba, doctor Merril Pauls said there had been "multiple times throughout the summer when we had to shut down beds in the emergency room" at Winnipeg's Health Sciences Centre because of the nursing shortage.

On one recent Sunday, he said, "We had too many people coming in and had no place to put them. We literally were double-bunking critical patients in a resuscitation bay.

"Our nurses are really working in crazy conditions."

It's a "really significant phenomenon going on across the country," the doctor added, and it's "getting worse."

- High turnover -

A recent survey by the Canadian Union of Public Employees, the country's largest labor union, found that 87 percent of nurses have considered leaving their job "because of the thankless and grueling working conditions."

"Even new graduates are quitting," Hoy said.

Federal health minister Jean-Yves Duclos has vowed to make it easier for foreign credentials to be recognized. That could help 11,000 internationally trained doctors and nurses get jobs in their field in Canada.

But that won't be nearly enough, with 34,400 nursing positions now vacant, according to government data.

Compounding the problem, many Canadians -- like Inard -- don't have a family doctor and turn to emergency rooms for care.

"It's just so difficult to find a family doctor," she said.

And a frequent shortage of regular hospital beds often means long waits to transfer patients out of ERs to wards.

Ontario passed a bill at the end of September permitting transfers of patients awaiting long-term care to facilities up to 150 kilometers away.

Provincial Health Minister Sylvia Jones said it would "ease pressures on crowded emergency departments."

But critics say it could force frail, elderly people into care homes far from their loved ones.

For now, almost everyone needing treatment is eventually seen. But delays can pose long-term consequences for patients' health.

"If a stroke patient doesn't get access to a clot-busting medicine fast, brain cells will die and the patient will end up being more disabled than they would have been," Pauls said.

Serious infections can be deadly if not treated in time. So, too, can cancers and other diseases, he added.

Pauls recalled routinely telling discharged patients "to come back if things get worse."

"But now they laugh at us. They say: 'You're crazy. There's no way I'm going to go through this again.'"

Y.Hara--JT