The Japan Times - Montana court rules for young people in landmark US climate trial

EUR -
AED 3.790595
AFN 77.430204
ALL 99.20841
AMD 405.948641
ANG 1.847466
AOA 943.795626
ARS 1087.128762
AUD 1.662815
AWG 1.858952
AZN 1.754363
BAM 1.955553
BBD 2.069738
BDT 125.014184
BGN 1.954683
BHD 0.388998
BIF 3034.316109
BMD 1.032034
BND 1.401223
BOB 7.099102
BRL 6.00572
BSD 1.02508
BTN 89.3147
BWP 14.405595
BYN 3.354776
BYR 20227.87484
BZD 2.059139
CAD 1.490026
CDF 2941.29778
CHF 0.939022
CLF 0.036865
CLP 1016.997864
CNY 7.41878
CNH 7.534548
COP 4295.760755
CRC 522.233929
CUC 1.032034
CUP 27.348912
CVE 110.251051
CZK 25.185563
DJF 182.546905
DKK 7.460411
DOP 63.701941
DZD 140.147257
EGP 51.926709
ERN 15.480516
ETB 131.128381
FJD 2.400151
FKP 0.84997
GBP 0.832398
GEL 2.930585
GGP 0.84997
GHS 15.658019
GIP 0.84997
GMD 74.822717
GNF 8859.879079
GTQ 7.931996
GYD 214.462867
HKD 8.036958
HNL 26.113949
HRK 7.615948
HTG 134.083036
HUF 407.562816
IDR 16847.96208
ILS 3.691845
IMP 0.84997
INR 89.904906
IQD 1342.83011
IRR 43448.649554
ISK 146.796546
JEP 0.84997
JMD 161.569559
JOD 0.732126
JPY 160.331193
KES 133.390518
KGS 90.251596
KHR 4122.478439
KMF 494.189607
KPW 928.831102
KRW 1502.693843
KWD 0.318599
KYD 0.854292
KZT 535.74222
LAK 22297.179039
LBP 91797.28613
LKR 307.081149
LRD 203.991227
LSL 19.385047
LTL 3.047329
LVL 0.624267
LYD 5.033363
MAD 10.347791
MDL 19.20557
MGA 4894.38078
MKD 61.50219
MMK 3352.007573
MNT 3506.853106
MOP 8.229259
MRU 40.952819
MUR 48.505407
MVR 15.892949
MWK 1777.575107
MXN 21.129491
MYR 4.586398
MZN 65.884855
NAD 19.385047
NGN 1539.000309
NIO 37.725227
NOK 11.724056
NPR 142.90392
NZD 1.84149
OMR 0.397326
PAB 1.02507
PEN 3.820917
PGK 4.11348
PHP 60.152148
PKR 286.004387
PLN 4.224325
PYG 8082.97737
QAR 3.737927
RON 4.97688
RSD 117.112136
RUB 102.817466
RWF 1449.016676
SAR 3.871057
SBD 8.746683
SCR 14.792122
SDG 620.252836
SEK 11.41266
SGD 1.400625
SHP 0.84997
SLE 23.678277
SLL 21641.245911
SOS 585.825883
SRD 36.229581
STD 21361.029045
SVC 8.969996
SYP 13418.511652
SZL 19.378736
THB 34.944605
TJS 11.173424
TMT 3.612121
TND 3.309081
TOP 2.417124
TRY 37.11557
TTD 6.950121
TWD 33.962086
TZS 2627.32123
UAH 42.872776
UGX 3770.522967
USD 1.032034
UYU 44.433733
UZS 13311.315899
VES 61.49531
VND 25986.626963
VUV 122.5252
WST 2.89055
XAF 655.874021
XAG 0.03265
XAU 0.000367
XCD 2.789125
XDR 0.786201
XOF 655.874021
XPF 119.331742
YER 256.774905
ZAR 19.374021
ZMK 9289.552181
ZMW 28.779359
ZWL 332.314666
  • RBGPF

    0.2700

    66.27

    +0.41%

  • SCS

    -0.4100

    11.07

    -3.7%

  • RIO

    -0.5600

    59.85

    -0.94%

  • RELX

    -0.0400

    49.85

    -0.08%

  • AZN

    -0.9000

    69.86

    -1.29%

  • BCC

    -1.0200

    125.14

    -0.82%

  • GSK

    -0.3700

    34.9

    -1.06%

  • CMSC

    -0.1200

    23.35

    -0.51%

  • BCE

    0.2400

    24.03

    +1%

  • NGG

    0.6100

    62.01

    +0.98%

  • RYCEF

    -0.1400

    7.35

    -1.9%

  • JRI

    -0.0700

    12.46

    -0.56%

  • CMSD

    -0.0900

    23.75

    -0.38%

  • VOD

    -0.0500

    8.49

    -0.59%

  • BTI

    0.1000

    39.74

    +0.25%

  • BP

    -0.1900

    30.87

    -0.62%

Montana court rules for young people in landmark US climate trial
Montana court rules for young people in landmark US climate trial / Photo: CHIP SOMODEVILLA - GETTY IMAGES/AFP/File

Montana court rules for young people in landmark US climate trial

In a landmark climate trial, a Montana court on Monday ruled in favor of a group of youths who accused the western US state of violating their rights to a clean environment.

Text size:

District Court Judge Kathy Seeley said a state law preventing agencies from considering the impacts of greenhouse gases when issuing permits for fossil fuel development was unconstitutional.

The case, Held v. State of Montana -- brought by plaintiffs ranging in age from five to 22 -- has been closely watched because it could bolster similar litigation that has been filed across the country.

"By prohibiting analysis of GHG0 (greenhouse gas) emissions and corresponding impacts to the climate... the MEPA (Montana Environmental Policy Act) Limitation violates Youth Plaintiffs' right to a clean and healthful environment and is unconstitutional on its face," Seeley wrote.

"Plaintiffs have a fundamental constitutional right to a clean and healthful environment, which includes climate as part of the environmental life-support system," Seeley added in her more than 100-page ruling.

The case was the first involving a constitutional claim against a state and also represented a rare instance in which climate experts were questioned on the witness stand.

Julia Olson, executive director of the nonprofit Our Children's Trust, which represented the plaintiffs, welcomed the ruling as a "huge win for Montana, for youth, for democracy, and for our climate."

"Today, for the first time in US history, a court ruled on the merits of a case that the government violated the constitutional rights of children through laws and actions that promote fossil fuels, ignore climate change, and disproportionately imperil young people," Olson said in a statement.

"As fires rage in the West, fueled by fossil fuel pollution, today's ruling in Montana is a game-changer that marks a turning point in this generation's efforts to save the planet from the devastating effects of human-caused climate chaos."

- 'Dystopian movie' -

At the heart of the case was a provision within the fossil fuel-friendly state's constitution that says: "The state and each person shall maintain and improve a clean and healthful environment in Montana for present and future generations."

The youths said they had been harmed by the "dangerous impacts of fossil fuels and the climate crisis," with children "uniquely vulnerable" to its worsening impacts.

During closing arguments, Nate Bellinger of Our Children's Trust said his clients were asking "that their government embrace its constitutional responsibility to alleviate the harms of its own conduct."

"The plaintiffs acknowledge that the work to stop and reverse climate change will be a lifetime journey, but they are asking this court for help," he said.

Montana Assistant Attorney General Michael Russell on the other hand argued that energy policy should be decided by the people through their representatives in the legislature.

"This case has received national attention in part because it has been billed or at least perceived as a sort of referendum on climate change," he said.

Russell said that while the state accepted that man-made emissions were responsible for warming, expert witnesses had not been able to quantify the extent to which Montana's laws were responsible for impacts on the ground.

The trial began on June 12 and concluded a few days earlier than expected after Montana declined to call to the stand several experts, including its only climate scientist, Judith Curry.

Over the course of the proceedings, the court heard testimony from the plaintiffs about ways their health, emotional wellbeing, family finances and cultural traditions had been impacted.

Lead plaintiff Rikki Held, 22, whose family runs a ranch in Montana, said that their livelihoods and quality of life had been increasingly impacted by wildfires, extreme temperatures and drought.

Claire Vlases, 20, said: "When I think about summer, I think about smoke. It sounds like a dystopian movie, but it's real life."

K.Nakajima--JT