The Japan Times - What to make of Trump's Guantanamo plan for migrants

EUR -
AED 3.814606
AFN 78.415845
ALL 99.726864
AMD 412.675093
ANG 1.871094
AOA 947.173661
ARS 1091.38173
AUD 1.669199
AWG 1.872017
AZN 1.769687
BAM 1.956944
BBD 2.096195
BDT 126.599749
BGN 1.957765
BHD 0.391529
BIF 3073.096669
BMD 1.038567
BND 1.408876
BOB 7.174091
BRL 6.063679
BSD 1.038192
BTN 89.881385
BWP 14.460245
BYN 3.397472
BYR 20355.916977
BZD 2.085389
CAD 1.507294
CDF 2963.032577
CHF 0.945143
CLF 0.03699
CLP 1020.662705
CNY 7.463875
CNH 7.59794
COP 4367.175045
CRC 523.698614
CUC 1.038567
CUP 27.522031
CVE 110.326846
CZK 25.180104
DJF 184.57457
DKK 7.461654
DOP 64.137498
DZD 140.46937
EGP 52.162976
ERN 15.578508
ETB 132.98733
FJD 2.411453
FKP 0.85535
GBP 0.836841
GEL 2.970708
GGP 0.85535
GHS 15.884057
GIP 0.85535
GMD 75.300121
GNF 8973.944144
GTQ 8.030695
GYD 217.20385
HKD 8.092184
HNL 26.447462
HRK 7.664156
HTG 135.799394
HUF 407.745458
IDR 16986.078007
ILS 3.712276
IMP 0.85535
INR 89.974971
IQD 1359.995114
IRR 43723.679179
ISK 146.698017
JEP 0.85535
JMD 163.730206
JOD 0.736556
JPY 161.001287
KES 134.186829
KGS 90.8231
KHR 4177.38195
KMF 491.086896
KPW 934.710589
KRW 1513.421283
KWD 0.320367
KYD 0.865193
KZT 537.956384
LAK 22586.879075
LBP 92969.011081
LKR 309.390884
LRD 206.597802
LSL 19.37863
LTL 3.066619
LVL 0.628219
LYD 5.096808
MAD 10.421193
MDL 19.383052
MGA 4827.752792
MKD 61.607882
MMK 3373.22573
MNT 3529.051432
MOP 8.333652
MRU 41.590316
MUR 48.449553
MVR 16.004713
MWK 1800.226492
MXN 21.477429
MYR 4.626857
MZN 66.375221
NAD 19.37863
NGN 1560.966848
NIO 38.202335
NOK 11.741745
NPR 143.809231
NZD 1.838446
OMR 0.399809
PAB 1.038192
PEN 3.862158
PGK 4.227329
PHP 60.774915
PKR 289.5784
PLN 4.218305
PYG 8188.78753
QAR 3.784413
RON 4.977892
RSD 117.122378
RUB 102.38466
RWF 1473.640272
SAR 3.895516
SBD 8.779725
SCR 15.593159
SDG 624.179235
SEK 11.499079
SGD 1.41066
SHP 0.85535
SLE 23.757264
SLL 21778.234665
SOS 593.338322
SRD 36.453193
STD 21496.24403
SVC 9.084005
SYP 13503.450624
SZL 19.366322
THB 35.080762
TJS 11.352473
TMT 3.645371
TND 3.315939
TOP 2.432432
TRY 37.228899
TTD 7.042015
TWD 34.21252
TZS 2648.346689
UAH 43.296671
UGX 3822.234649
USD 1.038567
UYU 44.926266
UZS 13470.875675
VES 60.624614
VND 26047.265193
VUV 123.300783
WST 2.908847
XAF 656.331241
XAG 0.033127
XAU 0.000371
XCD 2.80678
XDR 0.793637
XOF 656.318595
XPF 119.331742
YER 258.473449
ZAR 19.388544
ZMK 9348.35474
ZMW 29.043561
ZWL 334.418212
  • RBGPF

    2.7100

    64.91

    +4.18%

  • CMSC

    -0.2100

    23.47

    -0.89%

  • RIO

    -0.5000

    60.41

    -0.83%

  • JRI

    -0.0400

    12.53

    -0.32%

  • SCS

    -0.1600

    11.48

    -1.39%

  • AZN

    -0.4800

    70.76

    -0.68%

  • RYCEF

    0.0400

    7.49

    +0.53%

  • GSK

    -0.0900

    35.27

    -0.26%

  • BCC

    -2.5000

    126.16

    -1.98%

  • NGG

    -0.3400

    61.4

    -0.55%

  • RELX

    -0.4600

    49.89

    -0.92%

  • CMSD

    -0.3800

    23.84

    -1.59%

  • BP

    -0.5500

    31.06

    -1.77%

  • BCE

    -0.1100

    23.79

    -0.46%

  • VOD

    -0.0700

    8.54

    -0.82%

  • BTI

    -0.0400

    39.64

    -0.1%

What to make of Trump's Guantanamo plan for migrants
What to make of Trump's Guantanamo plan for migrants / Photo: Paul J. RICHARDS - AFP/File

What to make of Trump's Guantanamo plan for migrants

President Donald Trump has said he wants to send 30,000 "criminal illegal aliens" to the notorious Guantanamo Bay US military base in Cuba.

Text size:

The site houses the prison where hundreds of terror suspects labelled "enemy combatants" were held -- many for years without charge -- after the 9/11 attacks. Some were tortured.

Trump said this week he had ordered the construction of a detention center there to "double our capacity immediately" to hold undocumented migrants.

The plan has raised questions and concerns.

- Is it new? -

Guantanamo Bay has for decades been used to hold Caribbean asylum seekers and refugees caught at sea. Migrants are held in a different part of the base than that used for terror suspects.

In the 1990s, it was used to house tens of thousands of Haitians and Cubans who fled crises in their homelands.

They were accommodated in tent cities, many eventually sent home after being held at Guantanamo for years.

Trump's move would entail a significant expansion of what is known as the Guantanamo Migrant Operations Center (GMOC).

But Deepa Alagesan of the New York-based International Refugee Assistance Project (IRAP) says migrants are already being held "in inhuman conditions, and expanding the facility will be nothing short of disastrous."

In a report last September, the IRAP reported conditions at the GMOC including "undrinkable water and exposure to open sewage, inadequate schooling and medical care for children, and collective punishment of detained Cuban and Haitian refugees."

- Is it legal? -

"Some of them are so bad that we don't even trust the countries to hold them because we don't want them coming back," Trump said of the migrants he plans to ship off to Guantanamo -- adding it is "a tough place to get out of."

Bill Frelick, refugee and migrants director at Human Rights Watch told AFP that Trump's intention appears to be "to detain people indefinitely."

He explained there was leeway under domestic and international law to detain migrants administratively for short periods of time until they can be sent back to their home countries.

If they cannot be returned, "there is no longer a legitimate reason for the detention, and it becomes arbitrary," said Frelick.

Making matters worse, Guantanamo is a remote, closed military base "which the US government has used to evade legal protections and public scrutiny" in the past.

"When detention becomes prolonged and indefinite and untethered from proper oversight, it violates human rights and may amount to torture," said Frelick.

The UN human rights office said Friday that migrants should only be detained "as a last resort. And only in exceptional circumstances."

Observers say migrants in Guantanamo would find it hard to access legal counsel.

Many would be legitimate asylum seekers who have the right under US and international law to live and work in America while their applications are considered.

- Is it necessary? -

Thousands of undocumented migrants have been arrested since Trump's January 20 inauguration, including some accused of crimes.

An unknown number have been repatriated to Colombia, Mexico, Guatemala, Brazil and other countries. Trump has vowed to expel "millions."

The US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agency currently has funding for 41,500 detainee beds, according to the conservative Heritage Foundation think tank in Washington.

In a report this week, it said US military facilities such as Guantanamo "can play a central role in management of detention and deportation" -- and already have been used for this purpose under previous administrations including that of Joe Biden.

The United States leases the site holding the prison from Cuba under a treaty dating back to 1903.

The communist government in Havana considers it an illegal occupation, but the US Department of State website states the lease was the product of "international agreement and treaty" and can only be ended by mutual agreement.

M.Sugiyama--JT