The Japan Times - Nobel physics winner wanted to topple quantum theory he vindicated

EUR -
AED 3.823403
AFN 79.112634
ALL 98.10997
AMD 415.0708
ANG 1.876424
AOA 950.914404
ARS 1090.13111
AUD 1.659265
AWG 1.876324
AZN 1.780543
BAM 1.949902
BBD 2.102152
BDT 126.965967
BGN 1.955843
BHD 0.392336
BIF 3034.387996
BMD 1.040956
BND 1.408845
BOB 7.194067
BRL 6.185046
BSD 1.041156
BTN 90.014168
BWP 14.400374
BYN 3.407211
BYR 20402.746043
BZD 2.091384
CAD 1.498212
CDF 2961.52069
CHF 0.943445
CLF 0.037397
CLP 1031.910761
CNY 7.570149
CNH 7.580276
COP 4435.515352
CRC 523.618731
CUC 1.040956
CUP 27.585345
CVE 110.670924
CZK 25.141905
DJF 184.998195
DKK 7.460743
DOP 63.925349
DZD 140.627973
EGP 52.378434
ERN 15.614346
ETB 131.212813
FJD 2.408562
FKP 0.857318
GBP 0.845132
GEL 2.976774
GGP 0.857318
GHS 15.832297
GIP 0.857318
GMD 75.989901
GNF 9010.518536
GTQ 8.047658
GYD 217.718333
HKD 8.106452
HNL 26.542023
HRK 7.681788
HTG 135.959418
HUF 410.896542
IDR 16942.710963
ILS 3.675877
IMP 0.857318
INR 90.014678
IQD 1363.652924
IRR 43824.26542
ISK 146.118712
JEP 0.857318
JMD 163.365869
JOD 0.738454
JPY 162.744156
KES 134.803819
KGS 91.031653
KHR 4196.095255
KMF 491.962147
KPW 936.860903
KRW 1496.551746
KWD 0.320917
KYD 0.867671
KZT 542.362128
LAK 22692.850134
LBP 93196.569507
LKR 310.911084
LRD 202.934565
LSL 19.247218
LTL 3.073674
LVL 0.629664
LYD 5.11628
MAD 10.40592
MDL 19.417176
MGA 4913.314063
MKD 61.532474
MMK 3380.985882
MNT 3537.170063
MOP 8.351798
MRU 41.513457
MUR 48.352199
MVR 16.041213
MWK 1807.618576
MXN 21.341379
MYR 4.624455
MZN 66.527331
NAD 19.247084
NGN 1620.768943
NIO 38.306805
NOK 11.742457
NPR 144.023067
NZD 1.8376
OMR 0.400687
PAB 1.041156
PEN 3.870797
PGK 4.166168
PHP 60.73249
PKR 290.062382
PLN 4.224599
PYG 8235.091411
QAR 3.79012
RON 4.975877
RSD 117.153392
RUB 103.312946
RWF 1449.011352
SAR 3.903939
SBD 8.821823
SCR 14.836374
SDG 625.615326
SEK 11.461935
SGD 1.410709
SHP 0.857318
SLE 23.62895
SLL 21828.335792
SOS 594.901562
SRD 36.51657
STD 21545.696434
SVC 9.110444
SYP 13534.515498
SZL 19.247678
THB 35.29727
TJS 11.39496
TMT 3.653757
TND 3.326376
TOP 2.438027
TRY 37.109758
TTD 7.072641
TWD 34.026804
TZS 2628.415263
UAH 43.728335
UGX 3831.429522
USD 1.040956
UYU 45.562189
UZS 13537.638308
VES 57.972478
VND 26117.596848
VUV 123.584438
WST 2.915539
XAF 653.982049
XAG 0.033826
XAU 0.000378
XCD 2.813236
XDR 0.802178
XOF 654.229378
XPF 119.331742
YER 259.250465
ZAR 19.26425
ZMK 9369.860898
ZMW 29.021522
ZWL 335.187546
  • BCC

    -1.2000

    127.92

    -0.94%

  • JRI

    -0.0400

    12.53

    -0.32%

  • BCE

    -0.2400

    23.15

    -1.04%

  • RBGPF

    0.1600

    62.36

    +0.26%

  • NGG

    -1.5400

    60.05

    -2.56%

  • GSK

    -0.3500

    33.43

    -1.05%

  • CMSD

    -0.0400

    23.96

    -0.17%

  • RIO

    -0.6100

    61.12

    -1%

  • SCS

    -0.2200

    11.58

    -1.9%

  • AZN

    0.2400

    68.2

    +0.35%

  • CMSC

    -0.0600

    23.49

    -0.26%

  • RELX

    -0.2900

    49.26

    -0.59%

  • RYCEF

    0.1500

    7.42

    +2.02%

  • VOD

    -0.1700

    8.38

    -2.03%

  • BTI

    -0.1600

    36.57

    -0.44%

  • BP

    -0.3900

    31.13

    -1.25%

Nobel physics winner wanted to topple quantum theory he vindicated
Nobel physics winner wanted to topple quantum theory he vindicated / Photo: Remi Vorano - AFP

Nobel physics winner wanted to topple quantum theory he vindicated

American physicist John Clauser won the 2022 Nobel Prize for a groundbreaking experiment vindicating quantum mechanics -- a fundamental theory governing the subatomic world that is today the foundation for an emerging class of ultra-powerful computers.

Text size:

But when he carried out his work in the 1970s, Clauser was actually hoping for the opposite result: to upend the field and prove Albert Einstein had been right to dismiss it, he told AFP in an interview.

"The truth is that I strongly hoped that Einstein would win, which would mean that quantum mechanics was giving incorrect predictions," the 79-year-old said, speaking by telephone from his home in Walnut Creek, just outside San Francisco.

Born in Pasadena in 1942, Clauser credits his father, an engineer who designed planes in the war and founded the aeronautics department at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, for instilling in him a lifelong love of science.

"I used to wander around his laboratory and say 'Wow, oh boy, when I grow up I want to be a scientist so I can play with these fun toys too.'"

As a graduate student at Columbia in the mid-1960s, he grew interested in quantum physics alongside his thesis work on radio astronomy.

- Quantum entanglement -

According to quantum mechanics, two or more particles can exist in what's called an entangled state -- what happens to one in an entangled pair determines what happens to the other, no matter their distance.

The fact that this occurred instantly contradicted Einstein's theory of relativity which held that nothing -- including information -- can travel faster than the speed of light.

In 1935 he dismissed this element of quantum entanglement -- called nonlocality -- as "spooky action at a distance."

Einstein instead believed that "hidden variables" that instructed the particles what state to take must be at play, placing him at odds with his great friend but intellectual adversary Niels Bohr, a founding father of quantum theory.

In 1964, the Northern Irish physicist John Bell proposed a theoretical way to measure whether there were in fact hidden variables inside quantum particles. Clauser realized he could resolve the long standing Bohr-Einstein debate if he could create the right experiment.

"My thesis advisor thought it was a distraction from my work in astrophysics," he recalled, but undeterred, he wrote to Bell, who encouraged him to take up the idea.

It wasn't until Clauser had completed his doctorate and taken up a job at UC Berkeley that he was actually able to start working on the experiment, along with collaborator Stuart Freedman.

They focused a laser on calcium atoms, making it emit particles of entangled photon pairs that shot off in opposite directions, and used filters set to the side to measure whether they were correlated.

After hundreds of thousands of runs, they found the pairs correlated more than Einstein would have predicted, proving the reality of "spooky action" with hard data.

At the time, leading lights of the field were unimpressed, said Clauser, including the renowned physicist Richard Feynman who told him the work was "totally silly, you're wasting everybody's time and money" and threw him out his office.

Questioning the foundation of quantum mechanics was deemed unnecessary.

- Quantum computing -

That wasn't the view of the Nobel committee, who awarded Clauser, Alain Aspect of France, and Anton Zeilinger of Austria the world's most prestigious science prize for their pioneering work in advancing the field.

"It took a long time for people to realize the importance of the work," chuckled Clauser.

"But I suppose it is a certain vindication, everyone was telling me it was silly."

Einstein's theory had more appeal to Clauser than Bohr's, which he confessed to not fully grasping.

But over time, he came to realize the true value of his and his co-winners' experiments. Demonstrating that a single bit of information can be distributed through space is today at the core of quantum computers.

Clauser pointed to China's quantum-encrypted Micius communications satellite, which relies on entangled photons thousands of kilometers apart.

"We did not prove what quantum mechanics is -- we proved what quantum mechanics isn't," he said, "and knowing what it is not then has practical applications."

T.Ueda--JT